Vikings/Saints

Vhawk413 · Posts: 123 Join date: 2008-03-13

Saints get
DE Will Smith 92 26

Vikings get
DE Elvis Dumervil 83 24
1st round pick

_________________

Jeb_Woody · Posts: 72 Join date: 2008-03-13

I vote no,

a 1st is not enough to make up the difference between the two DE's

Brianeal23 · Posts: 69 Join date: 2008-03-13

Vhawk413 wrote:

Saints get
DE Will Smith 92 26

Vikings get
DE Elvis Dumervil 83 24
1st round pick

I say yes. Dumervil is 2 years younger and a 1st definitely makes up for the 9 point difference. I mean, think about it, practically a rookie 83 overall DE and another 82+ rookie is enough for Smith IMO.

mksadng · Posts: 4 Join date: 2008-03-28

I agree